Hostname: page-component-788cddb947-2s2w2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-10-18T00:36:05.388Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Making Cairo modern? Innovation, urban form and the development of suburbia, c. 1880–1922

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 July 2013

JAMES MOORE
JAMES MOORE*
Affiliation:
School of Historical Studies, University of Leicester, Leicester LE1 7RH, UK
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract:

Cairo has often been seen as a ‘dual city’ divided between a ‘modern’ European city and a historic ‘traditional’ core. This article challenges this view through a historical exploration of suburban Cairo, a subject neglected by mainstream urban historians. A comparative examination of Ismailiyah, Garden City, Zamalek, Maadi, Helwan and Heliopolis illustrates that these suburbs took very different forms and reflected a wide range of historical and contemporary architectural tastes and design perspectives. Not all suburban developments were products of modern technical innovations and by 1922 no suburb had a majority of European residents. The use of the term ‘modern’ to characterize Cairo's suburbs therefore has the tendency to privilege western concepts of the modern and obscure the complexities of suburban social and economic development.

Type
Research Article
Information
Urban History , Volume 41 , Issue 1 , February 2014 , pp. 81 - 104
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Abu-Lughod, J., ‘Tale of two cities: the origins of modern Cairo’, Comparative Studies in Society and History, 7 (1965), 429–57CrossRefGoogle Scholar. See also Abu-Lughod, J., Cairo: 1001 Years of the City Victorious (Princeton, 1971)Google Scholar.

2 Abu-Lughod, ‘Tale of two cities’, 429. The term ‘traditional’ is preferred here to ‘Islamic’ as many aspects of the older city had their roots in pre-Islamic society and not all parts of the older city were Islamic. See Brown, K., ‘The uses of a concept: “the Muslim city”’, in Brown, K.et al., Middle Eastern Cities in Comparative Perspective (London, 1986), 73–82Google Scholar.

3 Raymond, A., Cairo: City of History (Cairo, 2007), 333Google Scholar.

4 See Chaichian, M., Town and Country in the Middle East, Iran and Egypt in the Transition to Globalisation, 1800–1970 (Plymouth, 2009), 162Google Scholar.

5 Kramer, G., ‘Moving out of place: minorities in Middle Eastern urban studies, 1800–1914’, in Sluglett, P. (ed.), The Urban Social History of the Middle East, 1750–1950 (Cairo, 2009), 182–223, esp. 216–17Google Scholar.

6 Nield, S., ‘Colonial urbanism: the development of Madras City in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries’, Modern Asian Studies, 13 (1979), 217–46CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Chattopadhyay, S., ‘Blurring boundaries: the limits of “white town” in colonial Calcutta’, Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians, 59 (2000), 154–79CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 Chaichian, Town and Country, 21–2; Quataert, D., ‘Ottoman handicrafts and industry in the age of European industrial hegemony, 1800–1914’, Review of the Fernand Braudel Center, 11 (1988), 169–78Google Scholar.

8 Celik, Z., ‘New approaches on the non-western city’, Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians, 58 (1999), 374–81Google Scholar.

9 Abu-Lughod, ‘Tale of two cities’.

10 Ibid., 429–30; Chaichian, Town and Country, 161–3.

11 For the classic account, see Gran, P., Islamic Roots of Capitalism, Egypt 1760–1840 (Austin, 1979)Google Scholar.

12 Deeb, M., ‘The socioeconomic role of the local foreign minorities in modern Egypt, 1805–1961’, International Journal of Middle Eastern Studies, 9 (1978) 11–22CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

13 Kitroeff, A., The Greeks in Egypt 1919–1937: Ethnicity and Class (London, 1989)Google Scholar.

14 Goldfinch, G., Steel in the Sand: The History of Egypt and its Railways, new edn (London, 2011)Google Scholar.

15 Baer, G., ‘The beginnings of urbanization’, in Studies in the Social History of Modern Egypt (Chicago, 1969)Google Scholar.

16 Ibid., 134–5.

17 Azab, K., ‘Shubra’, in The Photographic Memory of Cairo (Alexandria, 2009), u.p.Google Scholar

18 Baer, ‘Beginnings’, 144.

19 The major study is Issawi, C., Egypt: An Economic and Social Analysis (Oxford, 1947)Google Scholar; Owen, E., ‘Lord Cromer and the development of Egyptian industry 1883–1907’, Middle Eastern Studies, 2 (1966), 282–301CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

20 Baer, ‘Beginnings’, 143.

21 McManus, R. and Ethington, P., ‘Suburbs in transition: new approaches to suburban history’, Urban History, 34 (2007), 317–37CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

22 For recent discussion of suburban typologies, see Hinchcliffe, T., ‘Elusive suburbs, endless variation’, Journal of Urban History, 31 (2005), 899–906CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

23 I use the term ‘satellite’ in the classical sense. See Schnore, L., ‘Satellites and suburbs’, Social Forces, 36 (1957), 121–7CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

24 Abu-Lughod, ‘Tale of two cities’, 438.

25 Colvin, A., The Making of Modern Egypt (London, 1906), 289Google Scholar.

26 Nicohosoff, A., Map of Cairo (Alexandria, 1933)Google Scholar.

27 Baer, G., ‘The beginnings of municipal government in Egypt’, Middle East Studies, 4 (1968), 118–40CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

28 Baer, G., ‘The evolution of private land ownership in Egypt and the Fertile Crescent’, in Issawi, C. (ed.), The Economic History of the Middle East (Chicago, 1975), 79–90, esp. 81Google Scholar.

29 Warner, N., ‘Sources for architectural and urban history, Charles Goad and the fire insurance plans of Egypt (1898–1910)’, in Volait, M. (ed.), Le Caire-Alexandrie: architectures européennes, 1850–1950 (Cairo, 2004), 219–41, esp. 235Google Scholar.

30 Ener, M., ‘Prohibitions on begging and loitering in nineteenth-century Egypt’, Die Welt des Islams, new ser., 39 (1999), 319–39CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Letter, A Traveller, Egyptian Gazette, 8 Mar. 1909; Mansfield, P., The British in Egypt (Newton Abbot, 1973), 131Google Scholar. In 1906, there were 3,201 recorded felonies including 741 murders and 392 attempted murders.

31 The subject of a very famous picture postcard of the city.

32 Egyptian Gazette, 16 Oct. 1919, 26 Apr. 1921.

33 Egyptian Gazette, 20–4 Mar. 1919.

34 Azab, Photographic.

35 Wilkinson, J. Gardner, A Handbook for Travellers in Egypt (London, 1867), 109Google Scholar.

36 Ibid., 111, 113.

37 Raafat, S., Cairo: The Glory Years (Cairo, 2005), 20Google Scholar.

38 See Warner, ‘Sources’, 219–41.

39 Egyptian Gazette, 16 Mar. 1906.

40 Raafat, Cairo, 19–23.

41 See photograph in Azab, Photographic, u.n.

42 Howard, E., Tomorrow: A Peaceful Way to Real Reform (London, 1898)Google Scholar, Howard, E., Garden Cities of Tomorrow (London, 1902)Google Scholar.

43 Raafat, Cairo, 89; Egyptian Gazette, 8 Sep. 1905.

44 Raafat, Cairo, 89–92.

45 Ibid., 100–7.

46 Ibid., 123–5. One feddan equals 1.038 acres.

47 El Messiri, N., ‘A changing perception of public gardens’, in Bianca, S. and Jodidio, P. (eds.), Cairo: Revitalising a Historic Metropolis (Cairo, 2004), 221–3, esp. 226Google Scholar.

48 Egyptian Gazette, 2 Dec. 1905.

49 Egyptian Gazette, 9 Jul. 1907.

50 Cairo Times, 30 Nov. 2000.

51 Egyptian Standard, 2 Dec. 1907.

52 According the Egyptian Commercial Directory of 1913, see Raafat, Cairo, 135–6.

53 Raafat, Cairo, 164–6.

54 Cairo Times, 1 Feb. 2000.

55 Cairo Times, 17 Feb. 2000.

56 Cairo Times, 4 Feb. 1999.

57 Egyptian Daily Press, 5 Jul. 1910.

58 Raafat, Cairo, 123–37.

59 Al Ahram, 14 Jun. 2004 (in Arabic).

60 Baedeker, K., Egypt and the Sudan, 7th edn (Leipzig and New York, 1914), xxiiGoogle Scholar; Egyptian Gazette, 16 Feb. 1904.

61 El Messiri, ‘Public gardens’, 229.

62 Hardman, E. Zimmerli, From Camp Caesar to Cleopatra's Pool: A Swiss Childhood in Alexandria 1934–1950 (Alexandria, 2008), 5–7Google Scholar.

63 Egyptian Gazette, 29 Apr. 1904.

64 Raafat, S., Maadi 1904–1962; Society & History in a Cairo Suburb (Cairo, 1994), 17–23Google Scholar.

65 Egyptian Gazette, 30 Apr. 1904.

66 Raafat, Maadi, 17.

67 Egyptian Gazette, 2 Jun. 1909.

68 Raafat, Maadi, 22–3.

69 Ibid., 24.

70 Ibid., 29.

71 Ibid., 33.

72 For an overview of occupation, see ibid., 60–79.

73 Dobrowolska, A. and Dobrowolski, J., Heliopolis: Rebirth of the City of the Sun (Cairo, 2006), 42–7, 98Google Scholar.

74 Egyptian Gazette, 21 Aug. 1907.

75 I am grateful to shopkeepers in Boulevard Ismail for providing background information.

76 Dobrowolska and Dobrowolski, Heliopolis, 111–12.

77 Quoted in Dobrowolska and Dobrowolski, Heliopolis, 48.

78 A. Van Loo, ‘Ernest Jasper a Heliopolis, 1905–1916’, in Volait (ed.), Le Caire-Alexandrie, 121–37; Ormos, I., ‘Preservation and restoration: the methods of Max Herz Pasha, chief architect of the Comte de Conservation des Monuments de l'Art Arabe, 1890–1914’, in Edwards, J. (ed.), Historians in Cairo: Essays in Honor of George Scanlon (Cairo, 2002), 123–54Google Scholar.

79 Egyptian Gazette, 21 Aug. 1907.

80 Dobrowolska and Dobrowolski, Heliopolis, 97–8, 112–13. Perhaps the greatest shock was the liquidation of the Cassa di Sconto di Risparmio; see Egyptian Gazette, 5 Jul. 1907.

81 Egyptian Gazette, 21 Aug. 1907.

82 For example the corner of modern-day Baghdad St and Ramses St.

83 Dobrowolska and Dobrowolski, Heliopolis, 145–6.

84 Egyptian Mail, 19 Sep. 1919.

85 Brinton, J., The Mixed Courts of Egypt (Alexandria, 1930), 68Google Scholar; Egyptian Gazette, 28 Apr. 1921.

86 Dobrowalska and Dobrowolska, Heliopolis, 178.

87 Zeitlian, S., Armenians in Egypt: Contribution of Armenians to Medieval and Modern Egypt (Los Angeles, 2006), 159–61Google Scholar.

88 Egyptian Mail, 7 Nov. 1919; Egypt Daily Post, 30 Sep. 1910.

89 Egyptian Daily Post, 7 Sep. 1910.

90 Dobrowolska and Dobrowolski, Heliopolis, 178.

91 McLean, W., ‘Local government and town planning in Egypt’, Town Planning Review, 7 (1917), 83–91, esp. 93–6CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

92 Wright, G., ‘Tradition in the service of modernity: architecture and urbanism in French colonial policy, 1900–1930’, Journal of Modern History, 59 (1987), 291–316CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

93 Crosnier-Leconte, M., ‘History, architectures’, in Port-Said Architectures (Cairo, 2006), 313–34, esp. 323–4Google Scholar.