Hostname: page-component-6766d58669-kl59c Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-05-21T05:22:30.766Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

PERSISTENT STATES: LESSONS FOR SCOTTISH DEVOLUTION AND INDEPENDENCE

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 January 2023

Anton Muscatelli ,
Graeme Roy  and
Alex Trew Open the ORCID record for Alex Trew [Opens in a new window]
Anton Muscatelli
Affiliation:
Adam Smith Business School, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, United Kingdom
Graeme Roy
Affiliation:
Adam Smith Business School, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, United Kingdom
Alex Trew*
Affiliation:
Adam Smith Business School, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, United Kingdom
*
*Corresponding author. Email: alex.trew@glasgow.ac.uk
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The equilibrium size of a nation state is, in part, the result of a trade-off between the gains from scale economies in the provision of public services and the costs of applying uniform policy to heterogeneous cultural, institutional and geographical fundamentals. Changes in such fundamentals can thus place pressure on states to reform over time. We consider this dynamic state formation process in the context of Scotland within the United Kingdom. First, we review the recent research in economic history on the persistence and evolution of such fundamentals. Second, we consider the history of Scotland both before and after the 1707 Act of Union in the light of that broader economic history literature. We conclude with some implications of fundamental persistence for current debates on the place of Scotland within the United Kingdom.

Keywords

Scotlandpersistencestate formationH77N43N44

Information

Type
Scotland
Information
National Institute Economic Review , Volume 260: THE POLITICAL ECONOMY OF DEVOLUTION IN, AND SECESSION FROM, THE UK – PART ONE , Spring 2022 , pp. 51 - 63
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of National Institute Economic Review

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Article purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Acemoglu, D., Egorov, G. and Sonin, K. (2021), ‘Chapter 13: Institutional change and institutional persistence’, in Bisin, A. and Federico, G. (eds), Handbook of Historical Economics, London: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Acemoglu, D., Johnson, S. and Robinson, J. (2001), ‘The Colonial Origins of Comparative Development: An Empirical Investigation’, American Economic Review, 91, 5, pp.1369–1401.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Alesina, A., Giuliano, P. and Nunn, N. (2013), ‘On the Origins of Gender Roles: Women and the Plough’, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 128, 2, pp. 469–530.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Alesina, A., Seror, M., Yang, D.Y., You, Y. and Zeng, W. (2020), ‘Persistence through revolutions’, Working paper 27053, National Bureau of Economic Research.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Alesina, A. and Spolaore, E. (1997), ‘On the number and size of nations’, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 112, pp. 1027–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Alesina, A. and Spolaore, E. (2003), The Size of Nations, Cambridge: MIT Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ashraf, Q.H. and Galor, O. (2013), ‘The “out of Africa” hypothesis, human genetic diversity, and comparative economic development’, American Economic Review, 103, 1, pp. 1–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ashraf, Q.H., Galor, O. and Klemp, M. (2018a), ‘Interpersonal diversity and socioeconomic disparities across populations: A reply to Rosenberg and Kang,’ Working paper 2018-14, Department of Economics, Brown University.Google Scholar
Ashraf, Q.H., Galor, O. and Klemp, M. (2018b), ‘The Out of Africa Hypothesis of Comparative Economic Development: Common Misconceptions’, Working paper 2018-13, Department of Economics, Brown University.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bai, Y. and Jia, R. (2020), The economic consequences of political hierarchy: Evidence from regime changes in China, AD1000-2000, Working paper 26652, National Bureau of Economic Research.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Becker, S.O., Boeckh, K., Hainz, C. and Woessmann, L. (2016), ‘The empire is dead, long live the empire! Long-run persistence of trust and corruption in the bureaucracy’, Economic Journal, 126, 590, pp. 40–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Becker, S.O., Heblich, S. and Sturm, D.M. (2021), ‘The impact of public employment: Evidence from Bonn’, Journal of Urban Economics, 122, p. 103291.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bell, D. and Eiser, D. (2015), ‘The economic case for further fiscal decentralisation to Scotland: Theoretical and empirical perspectives’, National Institute Economic Review, 233, pp. R27–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bleakley, H. and Lin, J. (2012), ‘Portage and path dependence’, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 127, 2, pp. 587–644.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Bolton, P. and Roland, G. (1997), ‘The breakup of nations: A political economy analysis’, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 112, 1057–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Boserup, E. (1970), Woman’s Role in Economic Development, London: George Allen and Unwin Ltd.Google Scholar
Bowles, S., Choi, J.-K., Hwang, S.-H. and Naidu, S. (2021), ‘Chapter 14: How institutions and cultures change: An evolutionary perspective’, in Bisin, A. and Giovanni, F. (eds), Handbook of Historical Economics, Amsterdam: Elsevier.Google Scholar
Brenøe, A.A. and Epper, T. (2019), ‘Parenting values moderate the intergenerational transmission of time preferences across four decades’, IZA Discussion Paper 12710.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chowdhury, S., Sutter, M. and Zimmerman, K.F. (2018), ‘Evaluating intergenerational persistence of economic preferences: A large scale experiment with families in Bangladesh’, IZA Discussion Paper 11337.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Comin, D.A., Easterly, B. and Gong, E. (2010), ‘Was the wealth of nations determined in 1000 B.C.?’, American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics, 2, 3, pp. 65–97.Google Scholar
Coward, B. and Gaunt, P. (2017), The Stuart Age: England, 1603–1714, 5th Edition, London: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Crafts, N. (2018), Forging Ahead, Falling Behind and Fighting Back: British Economic Growth from the Industrial Revolution to the Financial Crisis, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Curtice, J. and Montagu, I. (2018), Do Scotland and England & Wales Have Different Views About Immigration? in British Social Attitudes , Volume 38, London: The National Centre for Social Research.Google Scholar
Curtice, J. and Montagu, I. (2020), Is Brexit Fuelling Support for Independence?, London: The National Centre for Social Research.Google Scholar
Davis, D.R. and Weinstein, D.E. (2002), ‘Bones, bombs, and break points: The geography of economic activity’, American Economic Review, 92, 5, pp. 1269–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Deeming, C. (2021), Social Inequality: Is Scotland More Nordic than Liberal?, London: The National Centre for Social Research.Google Scholar
Desmet, K., Le Breton, M., Ortuño-Ortin, I. and Weber, S. (2011), ‘The stability and breakup of nations: A quantitative analysis’, Journal of Economic Growth, 16, p. 183.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Devine, T.M. (2003), Scotland’s Empire, 1600–1815, London: Penguin.Google Scholar
Devine, T.M. (2017), Independence or Union: Scotland’s Past and Scotland’s Present, London: Penguin.Google Scholar
Diamond, J. (1997), Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies, Norton & Co., New York.Google Scholar
Dohmen, T., Falk, A., Huffman, D. and Sunde, U. (2011), ‘The intergenerational transmission of risk and trust attitudes’, Review of Economic Studies, 79, 2, pp. 645–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Doornbos, M. (2006), Global Forces and State Restructuring: Dynamics of State Formation and Collapse, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Flückiger, M., Hornung, E., Larch, M., Ludwig, M. and Mees, A. (2021), ‘Roman transport network connectivity and economic integration’, Review of Economic Studies, forthcoming.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fry, M. (1987), Patronage and Principle, Aberdeen: Aberdeen University Press.Google Scholar
Funke, M., Schularick, M. and Trebesch, C. (2016), ‘Going to extremes: Politics after financial crises, 1870–2014’, European Economic Review, 88, pp. 227–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Heblich, S., Nagy, D., Trew, A. and Zylberberg, Y. (2021b), The Death and Life of Great British Cities, Mimeo.Google Scholar
Heblich, S., Trew, A. and Zylberberg, Y. (2021a), ‘East side story: Historical pollution and persistent neighborhood sorting’, Journal of Political Economy, 129, 5, pp. 1508–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hepburn, E., Keating, M. and McEwen, N. (2021), Scotland’s New Choice: Independence after Brexit, Edinburgh: Centre on Constitutional Change.Google Scholar
Jennings, C. and Sanchez-Pages, S. (2017), ‘Social capital, conflict and welfare’, Journal of Development Economics, 124, pp. 157–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
La Porta, R., Lopez-de-Silanes, F. and Shleifer, A. (2008), ‘The economic consequences of legal origins’, Journal of Economic Literature, 46, 2, pp. 285–332.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lin, J. and Rauch, F. (2020), ‘What future for history dependence in spatial economics?’, Regional Science and Urban Economics, 103628. Volume 94: https://www.sciencedirect.com/journal/regional-science-and-urban-economics/vol/94/suppl/C Google Scholar
Mayshar, J., Moav, O. and Pascali, L. (2022), ‘The origin of the state: Land productivity or appropriability?’, Journal of Political Economy, 130, 4, pp. 1091–1144.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Michaels, G. and Rauch, F. (2018), ‘Resetting the urban network: 117-2012’, Economic Journal, 128, pp. 378–412.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mullen, S. and Newman, S. (2018), ‘Slavery, Abolition and the University of Glasgow’. Report and recommendations of the University of Glasgow History of Slavery Steering Committee. http://eprints.gla.ac.uk/177383/.Google Scholar
Nunn, N. (2014), ‘Chapter 7: Historical development’, in Bisin, A. and Giovanni, F. (eds), Handbook of Economic Growth, Volume 2A, Amsterdam: Elsevier.Google Scholar
Nunn, N. (2020), ‘The historical roots of economic development’, Science, 367, p. eaaz9986.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Nunn, N. and Wantchekon, L. (2011), ‘The slave trade and the origins of mistrust in Africa’, American Economic Review, 101, 7, pp. 3221–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Olsson, O. and Hibbs, D. A. Jr (2005), ‘Biogeography and long-run economic development’, European Economic Review, 49, pp. 909—938.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Persson, T. and Tabellini, G. (2021), ‘Chapter 16: Culture, institutions, and policy’, in Bisin, A. and Giovanni, F. (eds), Handbook of Historical Economics, North Holland: Elsevier.Google Scholar
Redding, S.J., Sturm, D.M. and Wolf, N. (2011), ‘History and industry location: Evidence from German airports’, Review of Economics and Statistics, 93, 3, 814–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Renan, E. (1882), Qu’est-ce qu’une nation?, Paris: Presses-Pocket, 1992 (Translated by Ethan Rundell).Google Scholar
Rosenberg, N.A. and Kang, J.T.L. (2015), ‘Genetic diversity and societally important disparities’, Genetics, 201, 1, pp. 1–12.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Schlichte, K. (ed.) (2005), The Dynamics of States: The Formation and Crises of State Domination, London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Trew, A. (2014), ‘Spatial takeoff in the first industrial revolution’, Review of Economic Dynamics, 17, pp. 707–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Voigtländer, N. and Voth, H.-J. (2015), ‘Nazi indoctrination and anti-semitic beliefs in Germany’, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 112, 26, pp. 7931–6.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Voth, H.-J. (2012), ‘Catalonia’s fight for independence: Are there lessons from the Dutch revolt?’, CNN online, available online at https://edition.cnn.com/2012/11/21/business/catalonia-dutch-revolt-lessons. retrieved on 1 Mar. 2022.Google Scholar
Voth, H.-J. (2021), ‘Chapter 9: Persistence—myth and mystery’, in Bisin, A. and Federico, G. (eds), Handbook of Historical Economics, Amsterdam: Elsevier.Google Scholar