No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Civiles Principes and Persian Despots: Alexander Severus’ Admission Ritual in the Historia Augusta
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 16 December 2024
Abstract
This article argues that the Historia Augusta retrojected fourth-century rituals of the imperial court into its presentation of the reign of Severus Alexander in order to criticise the “oriental” and un-Roman practices of the contemporary emperors of the fourth century. The Historia Augusta’s two descriptions of Alexander Severus’ admission ritual (salutatio) are suffused with fourth-century ritual elements which have no place in the early third century. A simplistic reading might interpret these anachronisms as evidence of the HA’s sloppiness and incompetence. However, I argue instead that they are conscious and deliberate. These two descriptions highlight a contrast between the adoratio of the fourth century and the restrained and moderate civilitas of the traditional princeps, and the descriptions also innovatively present the adoratio as Persian. This article thus demonstrates the contemporary political argument of the Historia Augusta, which sought to contribute to wider intellectual debates about the ideal emperor and the importance of civilitas in the fourth century.
Information
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- © The Author(s), 2024. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of Cambridge Philological Society.
References
Alföldi, A. (1970): Die monarchische Repräsentation im römischen Kaiserreiche. Darmstadt.Google Scholar
Avery, W. (1940): “The “Adoratio Purpurae” and the Importance of the Imperial Purple in the Fourth Century of the Christian Era” in Memoirs of the American Academy in Rome 17: 66–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Babut, E.-Ch. (1916): “L’Adoration des Empereurs et les Origines de la Persécution de Dioclétien” in Revue Historique 123/2: 225–252.Google Scholar
Badel, C. (2007): “L’audience chez les sénateurs” in Caillet, J. and Sot, M. (eds.), L’audience: rituels et cadres spatiaux dans l’Antiquité et le haut Moyen Âge (Paris): 141–164.Google Scholar
Badel, C. (2009): “Adventus et salutatio” in Bérenger, A. and Perrin-Saminadayar, E. (eds.), Les Entrées Royales et Impériales: Histoire, Représentation et Diffusion d’une Cérémonie Publique, de l’Orient Ancien à Byzance (Paris): 157–175.Google Scholar
Baker, R. (2014): A Study of a Late Antique Corpus of Biographies [Historia Augusta]. PhD thesis: University of Oxford.Google Scholar
Baldwin, B. (2010): “‘Contemporary’” Allusions in the Historia Augusta” in Deroux, C. (ed.), Studies in Latin Literature and Roman History 15 (Bruxelles): 446–462.Google Scholar
Béranger, J. (1974): “L’Expression du pouvoir suprême dans l’Histoire Auguste” in Alföldi, A. and Straub, J. (eds.), Bonner Historia-Augusta-Colloquium 1971 (Bonn): 21-50.Google Scholar
Birley, A. (2006): “Rewriting Second and Third-century History in Late Antique Rome: The Historia Augusta” in Classica 19/1: 19–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Boak, A. (1919): The Master of the Offices in the Later Roman and Byzantine Empires. New York.Google Scholar
Bonament, G. and Paschoud, F. (2002) (eds): Historia Augustae Colloquim Perusinum. Bari.Google Scholar
Bordone, F. (2010): “La lingua e lo stile del Breviarium di Eutropio” in Annali Online di Lettere, Ferrara 2: 143–162.Google Scholar
Canepa, M. (2009): The Two Eyes of the Earth: Art and Ritual of Kingship Between Rome and Sasanian Iran. Berkeley.Google Scholar
Carlà-Uhink, F. and Rollinger, C. (eds.) (2023): The Tetrarchy as Ideology: Reconfigurations and Representations of an Imperial Power. Stuttgart.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chastagnol, A. (1983): “Étude sur la Vita Cari: Carin et Elagabal” in Chastagnol, A. and Straub, J. (eds.), Bonner Historia-Augusta-Colloquium 1979/1981 (Bonn): 99–113.Google Scholar
Chastagnol, A. (1988): “Le Formulaire de l’épigraphie latine officielle dans l’Antiquité tardive” in Donati, A. (ed.), La terza età dell’epigrafia: Colloquio AIEGL-Borghesi 86 (Bologna, ottobre 1986) (Faenza): 11–64.Google Scholar
Dack, E. van‘t (1991): “Alexandre le Grand dans l’HA: Vita Severi Alexandri 30.3 et 50.4” in Rosen, K. (ed.), Bonner Historia-Augusta-Colloquium 1986/1989 (Bonn): 41–60.Google Scholar
Davenport, C. (2022): “The Court and Ceremonial” in Kelly, B. and Hug, A. (eds.) The Roman Emperor and His Court c. 30 BC-c. AD 300. Vol. 1 (Cambridge): 288–317.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Delmaire, R. (1995): Les institutions du Bas-Empire romain de Constantin à Justinien. Vol 1: Les institutions civiles palatines. Paris.Google Scholar
Dessau, H. (1889): “Über Zeit und Persönlichkeit der Scriptores historiae Augustae” in Hermes 24: .Google Scholar
Diefenbach, S. (2019): “Zur Dynamik kaiserlicher Siegesrituale in der Spätantike. Konstantinopel und Rom im Vergleich” in Conrad, R., Drecoll, V. and Hirbodian, S. (eds.), Säkulare Prozessionen. Zur religiösen Grundierung von Umzügen, Einzügen und Aufmärschen (Tübingen): 63–110.Google Scholar
Doležal, S. (2009): “Some Remarks on the Origin of Προσκύνησις at the Late Antique Imperial Court” in Byzantion 79: 136–149.Google Scholar
Duindam, J. (1995): Myths of Power: Norbert Elias and the Early Modern European Court. Amsterdam.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Duindam, J. (2003): Vienna and Versailles: The Courts of Europe’s Dynastic Rivals, 1559-1780. Cambridge.Google Scholar
Duindam, J., Artan, T. and Kunt, M. (eds.) (2011): Royal Courts in Dynastic States and Empires: A Global Perspective. Leiden.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Eberlein, J. (1982): Apparitio regis – revelatio veritatis: Studien zur Darstellung des Vorhangs in der bildenden Kunst von der Spätantike bis zum Ende des Mittelalters. Wiesbaden.Google Scholar
Ensslin, W. (1939): “The End of the Principate” in Cook, S., Adcock, F., Charlesworth, M. and Baynes, N. (eds.), The Cambridge Ancient History. Vol. 12: The Imperial Crisis and Recovery A.D. 193-324 (Cambridge): 353–382.Google Scholar
Flower, R. (2015): “Tamquam Figmentum Hominis: Ammianus, Constantius II and the Portrayal of Imperial Ritual” in The Classical Quarterly 65/2: 822–835.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Flower, R. (2016): Imperial Invectives against Constantius II: Athanasius of Alexandria, History of the Arians, Hilary of Poitiers, Against Constantius and Lucifer of Cagliari, The Necessity of Dying for the Son of God. Liverpool.Google Scholar
Fowden, G. (1991): “Constantine’s Porphyry Column: The Earliest Literary Allusion” in The Journal of Roman Studies 81: 119–131.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
García Ruiz, M. (2008): “Una Lectura de la “Gratiarum Actio” de Claudio Mamertino a la Luz de los Primeros Escritos de Juliano” in Emerita: Revista de Lingüística y Filología Clásica 76/2: 231–252.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goldbeck, F. (2010): Salutationes: die Morgenbegrüßungen in Rom in der Republik und der frühen Kaiserzeit. Berlin.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Guidetti, F. (2018): “Gerarchie visibili: la rappresentazione dell’ordine cosmico e sociale nell’arte e nel cerimoniale tardoromani” in Tommasi, C., Santoprete, L. Soares and Seng, H. (eds.), Hierarchie und Ritual. Zur philosophischen Spiritualität in der Spätantike (Heidelberg): 9–42.Google Scholar
Haake, M. (2015): “‘In Search of Good Emperors.’ Emperors, Caesars and Usurpers in the Mirror of Antimonarchic Patterns in the Historia Augusta – Some Considerations” in Börm, H. (ed.), Antimonarchic Discourse in Antiquity (Stuttgart): 269–303.Google Scholar
Hächler, N. (2023): “The ‘Hammer of the Aristocracy’? Diocletian’s Reign and Its Consequences for the Amplissimus Ordo” in Carlà-Uhink, F. and Rollinger, C. (eds.), The Tetrarchy as Ideology: Reconfigurations and Representations of an Imperial Power (Stuttgart): 179–220.Google Scholar
Haehling, R. (1985): “Augustus in der Historia Augusta” in Chastagnol, A. and Straub, J. (eds.), Bonner Historia-Augusta-Colloquium 1982/1983 (Bonn): 197–220.Google Scholar
Herrmann-Otto, E. (1998): “Der Kaiser und die Gesellschaft des spätrömischen Reiches im Spiegel des Zeremoniells” in Kneissl, P. and Losemann, V. (eds.), Imperium Romanum: Studien zu Geschichte und Rezeption. Festschrift für Karl Christ zum 75. Geburtstag (Stuttgart): 346–369.Google Scholar
Hofmann, D. (2018): Griechische Weltgeschichte auf Latein: Iustins “Epitoma historiarum Pompei Trogi” und die Geschichtskonzeption des Pompeius Trogus. Stuttgart.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hönn, K. (1911): Quellenuntersuchungen zu den Viten des Heliogabalus und des Severus Alexander im Corpus der Scriptores Historiae Augustae. Leipzig.Google Scholar
Humphries, M. (2019): “Narrative and Subversion: Exemplary Rome and Imperial Misrule in Ammianus Marcellinus” in Ancient Narrative Supplementum 27: 233–254.Google Scholar
Icks, M. (2012): “Bad Emperors on the Rise: Negative assessments of imperial investitures, AD 284-395” in Klio 94/2: 462–481.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Icks, M. (2014) “Creating Tyrants in Ancient Rome: Character Assassination and Imperial Investiture” in Shiraev, E. and Icks, M. (eds.), Character Assassination through the Ages (New York): 83–100.Google Scholar
Johne, K.‐P. (1976): Kaiserbiographie und Senatsaristokratie: Untersuchungen zur Datierung und sozialen Herkunft der Historia Augusta. Berlin.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kelly, C. (1998): “Emperors, Government and Bureaucracy” in Cameron, A. and Garnsey, P. (eds.), The Cambridge Ancient History. Vol. 13: The Late Empire, AD 337-425 (Cambridge): 138–183.Google Scholar
Kolb, F. (1976a): “Herodian in der Historia Augusta” in Alföldi, A. and Straub, J. (eds.), Bonner Historia-Augusta-Colloquium 1972/1974 (Bonn): 143–152.Google Scholar
Kolb, F. (1976b): “Kleidungsstücke in der Historia Augusta: Textkonjekturen und -emendationen zu AS 33, 3. 41, 1. A 45, 5, mit einem Exkurs über die Dalalmatica” in Alföldi, A. and Straub, J. (eds.), Bonner Historia-Augusta-Colloquium 1972/1974 (Bonn): 153–171.Google Scholar
Lindholmer, M. O. (2021): Rituals of Power: The Roman Imperial Admission from the Severans to the Fourth Century. Thesis: University of St Andrews.Google Scholar
Lindholmer, M. O. (2024): “Civilitas, the Historia Augusta and the Ideal emperor in Late Antiquity” in Zecchini, G. (ed.), Historiae Augustae Colloquium Romanum (Bari, Edipuglia): 75–98.Google Scholar
Lindholmer, M. O. (2024a): “Re-evaluating the Introduction of the Adoratio” in Historia 73/3: 362–383.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lindholmer, M. O. (forthcoming 2025): “Adoratio, Persians and the Date of Justin’s Epitome” in The Classical Quarterly.Google Scholar
Lovotti, F. (2002): “Il Conferimento dei Poteri a Severo Alessandro” in Bonamente, G. and Paschoud, F. (eds.), Historiae Augustae Colloquium Perusinum (Bari): 345–354.Google Scholar
Lippold, A. (1998): Die Historia Augusta: Eine Sammlung römischer Kaiserbiographien aus der Zeit Konstantins. Stuttgart.Google Scholar
Mader, G. (2005): “History as Carnival, or Method and Madness in the Vita Heliogabali” Classical Antiquity 24/1: .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marcone, A. (1985): “A proposito della “civilitas” nel Tardo Impero: una nota” in Rivista Storica Italiana 97: 969–982.Google Scholar
Mastandrea, P. (2011): “Vita dei principi e Storia Romana, tra Simmaco e Giordane” in Cristante, L. and Ravalico, S. (eds.), Il calamo della memoria: Riuso di testi e mestiere letterario nella tarda antichità. Vol. 4 (Trieste): 207–245.Google Scholar
Mastandrea, P. (2014): “I Saturnalia di Macrobio e la Historia Augusta. Una questione di cronologia relativa” in Bertrand-Dagenbach, C. and Chausson, F. (eds.), Historiae Augustae Colloquium Nanceiense (Bari): 317–333.Google Scholar
Mayer, M. (2005): “Res publica bene gesta (HA, AS 58, 2)” in Bonamente, G. and Mayer, M. (eds.), Historiae Augustae Colloquium Barcinonense (Bari): 217–219.Google Scholar
Meißner, B. (1992): “Sum Enim Unus Ex Curiosis, Computerstudien Zum Stil Der Historia Augusta” in Rivista di cultura classica e medioevale 34: 47–79.Google Scholar
Molinier-Arbò, A. (2003): “Notes sur la pourpre dans l’Histoire Auguste” in Guillaumin, J.-Y. and Ratti, S. (eds.), Autour de Lactance: Hommages à Pierre Monat (Paris): 301–314.Google Scholar
Moreno Ferrero, I. (1999): “Severus Alexander’s severitas and the composition of the life” in Paschoud, F. (ed.), Historiae Augustae Colloquium Genevense (Bari): 191–216.Google Scholar
Moser, M. (2018): Emperors and Senators in the Reign of Constantius II. Cambridge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nardelli, J.-F. (2016): “Historia Augusta contra Christianos II: Nouvelles considérations sur la παιδεία païenne et sur l’ambiance antichrétienne dans l’Histoire Auguste” in Antiquité Tardive 24: 257–284.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Neri, V. (1984): Costanzo, Giuliano e l’Ideale del Civilis Princeps nelle Storie di Ammiano Marcellino. Bologna.Google Scholar
Neri, V. (1999): “Considerazioni sul tema della luxuria nell’Historia Augusta” in Paschoud, F. (ed.), Historiae Augustae Colloquium Genevense (Bari): 217–240.Google Scholar
Niccolai, L. (2023): Christianity, Philosophy and Roman Power: Constantine, Julian, and the Bishops on Exegesis and Empire. Cambridge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Noreña, C. (2011): Imperial Ideals in the Roman West: Representation, Circulation, Power. Cambridge.Google Scholar
Paschoud, F. (1999): “Propos sceptiques et iconoclastes sur Marius Maximus” in Historiae Augustae Colloquium Genevense (Bari): 241–254.Google Scholar
Pisapia, A. (1997): “La «civilitas» del principe. Considerazioni su una nozione politico-giuridica antica” in Scienza & politica 17: 87–102.Google Scholar
Ratti, S. (1996a): “La civilitas et la iustitia dans le Bréviaire d’Eutrope: des qualités de famille?” in Revue des Études Anciennes 98: 197–205.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ratti, S. (1996b): Les empereurs romains d’Auguste à Dioclétien dans le Bréviaire d’Eutrope. Paris.Google Scholar
Ratti, S. (2010): Antiquus error: Les ultimes feux de la résistance païenne. Turnhout.Google Scholar
Rees, R. (2001): “To Be and Not to Be: Pliny’s Paradoxical Trajan” in Bulletin of the Institute of Classical Studies 45/1: 149–168.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Reintjes, A. (1961): Untersuchungen zu den Beamten bei den Scriptores Historiae Augustae. Düsseldorf.Google Scholar
Rohrbacher, D. (2013): “The Sources of the Historia Augusta Re-Examined” in Histos 7: 146–180.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ruggini, C. (1991): “Elagabalo, Costantino e i culti “siriaci” nella Historia Augusta” in Bonamente, G. and Duval, N. (eds.) Historiae Augustae Colloquium Parisinum (Macerata): 123–147.Google Scholar
Saitta, B. (1993): La Civilitas di Teodorico. Rigore Amministrativo, Tolleranza Religiosa e Recupero dell’Antico nell’Italia Ostrogota. Roma.Google Scholar
Scheck, T. (2010): St. Jerome’s Commentaries on Galatians, Titus, and Philemon. Notre Dame.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Scheithauer, A. (2014): “Sind Gute Herrscher Kultiviert?” in Bertrand-Dagenbach, C. and Chausson, F. (eds.), Historiae Augustae Colloquium Nanciense (Bari): 457–474.Google Scholar
Schöpe, B. (2014): Der römische Kaiserhof in severischer Zeit (193-235 n. Chr.). Stuttgart.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Scivoletto, N. (1970): “La civilitas del IV secolo e il significato del Breviarium di Eutropio” in Giornale Italiano di Filologia 22: 14–45.Google Scholar
Seeck, O. (1893): “Admissionales” in Paulys Realencyclopädie der classischen Altertumswissenschaft 1/1: .Google Scholar
Smith, R. (2007): “The imperial court of the late Roman empire, c. AD 300-c. AD 450” in Spawforth, A. (ed.), The Court and Court Society in Ancient Monarchies (Cambridge): 157–232.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stern, H. (1954): “Remarks on the “Adoratio” under Diocletian” in Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes 17/1: 184–189.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stover, J. and Kestemont, M. (2016): “The Authorship of the Historia Augusta: Two New Computer Studies” in Bulletin of the Institute of Classical Studies 59/2: 140–157.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stover, J. and Woudhuysen, G. (2021): “Jordanes and the Date of the Epitome de Caesaribus” in Histos 15: 150–188.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stover, J. and Woudhuysen, G. (2023): The Lost History of Sextus Aurelius Victor. Edinburgh.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Straub, J. (1970): “Severus Alexander und die Mathematici” in Alföldi, A. and Straub, J. (eds.), Bonner Historia-Augusta-Colloquium 1968/1969 (Bonn): 247–272.Google Scholar
Straub, J. (1980): “Scurra Barbarus: Zum Bericht der Historia Augusta über das Ende des Severus Alexander” in Alföldi, A. and Straub, J. (eds.), Bonner Historia-Augusta-Colloquium 1977/1978 (Bonn): 233–255.Google Scholar
Syme, R. (1988): “The Date of Justin and the Discovery of Trogus” in Historia 37/3: 358–371.Google Scholar
Tantillo, I. (2015): “I Cerimoniali di Corte in Età Tardoromana (284-395 d.C.)” in Le Corti nell’Alto Medioevo. Spoleto.Google Scholar
Teja, R. (1993): “Il cerimoniale imperiale” in Carandini, A., Ruggini, L. and Giardina, A. (eds.), Storia di Roma. L’etá tardoantica: Crisi e trasformazioni. Vol. 3/1 (Turin): 613–642.Google Scholar
Tomei, M. (1992): “Nota sui giardini antichi del Palatino” in Mélanges de l’école française de Rome 104/2: 917–951.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Turcan, R. (1987): Vivre à la cour des Césars: d’Auguste à Dioclétien, Ier-IIIe siècle après J.-C. Paris.Google Scholar
Turcan, R. (1988): “Héliogabale précurseur de Constantin?” in Bulletin de l’Association Guillaume Budé: Lettres d’humanité 47: 38–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wallace-Hadrill, A. (1982): “Civilis princeps: between citizen and king” in Journal of Roman Studies 72: 32–48.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Winterling, A. (1999): Aula Caesaris: Studien zur Institutionalisierung des römischen Kaiserhofes in der Zeit von Augustus bis Commodus (31. v. Chr.-192 n. Chr.). Munich.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yardley, J. (2003): Justin and Pompeius Trogus: A Study of the Language of Justin’s Epitome of Trogus. Toronto.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zawadzki, T. (1997): “Palatium cum stagno: une source iconographique et épigraphique de l’Histoire Auguste (AS 26,9)” in Bonamente, G. and Rosen, K. (eds.), Historiae Augustae Colloquium Bonnense (Bari): 255–263.Google Scholar
Zecchini, G. (2016): “Per la datazione di Giustino” in Galimberti, A. and Zecchini, G. (eds.), Studi sull’Epitome di Giustino III. Il tardo ellenismo: I Parti e i Romani (Milan): 221–231.Google Scholar
Zinsli, S. (2005): “Gute Kaiser, schlechte Kaiser: Die eusebische Vita Constantini als Referenztext für die Vita Heliogabali” in Wiener Studien 118: .Google Scholar