Book contents
- NAFTA and Sustainable DevelopmentHistory, Experience, and Prospects for Reform
- Treaty Implementation for Sustainable Development
- NAFTA and Sustainable Development
- Copyright page
- Contents
- List of Editors and Contributors
- Book part
- Introduction
- Part I Process: NAFTA and NAAEC
- 1 Forgotten Promises
- 2 Should Citizens Expect Procedural Justice in Nonadversarial Processes? Spotlighting the Regression of the Citizen Submissions Process from NAAEC to CAFTA–DR
- 3 Choosing the Right Whistle
- 4 Pending Proceedings in the New Guidelines for Submissions on Enforcement Matters
- 5 Form over Substance
- Part II Specific Environmental Issues under NAFTA and NAAEC
- Part III Proposals for Reform and Lessons Going Forward
- Index
- References
4 - Pending Proceedings in the New Guidelines for Submissions on Enforcement Matters
An Improved Regression?
from Part I - Process: NAFTA and NAAEC
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 September 2015
Book contents
- NAFTA and Sustainable DevelopmentHistory, Experience, and Prospects for Reform
- Treaty Implementation for Sustainable Development
- NAFTA and Sustainable Development
- Copyright page
- Contents
- List of Editors and Contributors
- Book part
- Introduction
- Part I Process: NAFTA and NAAEC
- 1 Forgotten Promises
- 2 Should Citizens Expect Procedural Justice in Nonadversarial Processes? Spotlighting the Regression of the Citizen Submissions Process from NAAEC to CAFTA–DR
- 3 Choosing the Right Whistle
- 4 Pending Proceedings in the New Guidelines for Submissions on Enforcement Matters
- 5 Form over Substance
- Part II Specific Environmental Issues under NAFTA and NAAEC
- Part III Proposals for Reform and Lessons Going Forward
- Index
- References
Summary
A summary is not available for this content so a preview has been provided. Please use the Get access link above for information on how to access this content.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- NAFTA and Sustainable DevelopmentHistory, Experience, and Prospects for Reform, pp. 97 - 122Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2015
References
Primary Sources
Case concerning Kasikili/Sedudu Island (Botswana v Namibia) [1999] ICJ Rep 1045.Google Scholar
Case concerning the Territorial Dispute (Libyan Arab Jamahiriya v Chad), [1994] ICJ Rep 6.Google Scholar
North American Agreement on Environmental Cooperation, September 14, 1993, in force January 1, 1994, (1993) 32 ILM 1480; Can TS 1994 No 3.Google Scholar
Responsibilities and Obligations of States Sponsoring Persons and Entities with respect to Activities in the Area, Advisory Opinion (February 1, 2011).Google Scholar
Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, Vienna, May 23, 1969, in force January 27, 1980, 1155 UNTS 331; (1969) 8 ILM 679.Google Scholar
Secondary Sources
Commission for Environmental Cooperation, Bringing the Facts to Light: A Guide to Articles 14 and 15 of the North American Agreement on Environmental Cooperation (Montreal: Commission for Environmental Cooperation, 2000).Google Scholar
Commission for Environmental Cooperation, Guidelines for Submissions on Enforcement Matters under Articles 14 and 15 of the North American Agreement on Environmental Cooperation (Montreal: Commission for Environmental Cooperation, 2013).Google Scholar
SEM-00–006 (Tarahumara), Council Resolution 03–04 pursuant to Article 15(2) (April 22, 2003).Google Scholar
SEM-01–001 (Cytrar II), Council Resolution 02–13 pursuant to Article 15(2) (December 10, 2002).Google Scholar
SEM-02–003 (Pulp and Paper), Council Resolution 03–16 pursuant to Article 15(2) (December 11, 2003).Google Scholar
SEM-02–003 (Pulp and Paper), Recommendation pursuant to Article 15(1) (October 8, 2003).Google Scholar
SEM-02–004 (El Boludo Project), Recommendation pursuant to Article 15(1) (May 17, 2004).Google Scholar
SEM-03–003 (Lake Chapala II), Council Resolution 08–01 pursuant to Article 15(2) (May 30, 2008).Google Scholar
SEM-03–003 (Lake Chapala II), Recommendation pursuant to Article 15(1) (May 18, 2005).Google Scholar
SEM-04–005 (Coal-fired Power Plants), Government of the United States of America Supplemental Response pursuant to Article 14(3) (September 29, 2005).Google Scholar
SEM-04–005 (Coal-fired Power Plants), Recommendation pursuant to Article 15(1) (December 5, 2005).Google Scholar
SEM-05–001 (Crushed Gravel in Puerto Peñasco), Recommendation pursuant to Article 15(1) (October 24, 2005).Google Scholar
SEM-05–002 (Coronado Islands), Government of the United Mexican States Response pursuant to Article 14(3) (January 10, 2006).Google Scholar
SEM-05–002 (Coronado Islands), Recommendation pursuant to Article 15(1) (January 18, 2007).Google Scholar
SEM-06–003 and SEM-06–004 (Ex Hacienda El Hospital II and Ex Hacienda El Hospital III), Recommendation pursuant to Article 15(1) (May 12, 2008).Google Scholar
SEM-06–005 (Species at Risk), Council Resolution 10–05 pursuant to Article 15(2) (December 20, 2010).Google Scholar
SEM-06–005 (Species at Risk), Government of Canada Response pursuant to Article 14(3) (February 8, 2007).Google Scholar
SEM-06–006 (Los Remedios National Park), Government of the United Mexican States Supplemental Response pursuant to Article 21(1)(b) (February 26, 2008).Google Scholar
SEM-06–006 (Los Remedios National Park), Recommendation pursuant to Article 15(1) (March 20, 2008).Google Scholar
SEM-06–006 (Los Remedios National Park), Secretariat Information Request pursuant to Article 21(1)(b) (November 27, 2007).Google Scholar
SEM-07–001 (Minera San Xavier), Government of the United Mexican States Supplemental Response pursuant to Article 21(1)(b) (June 5, 2008).Google Scholar
SEM-07–001 (Minera San Xavier), Recommendation pursuant to Article 15(1) (July 15, 2009).Google Scholar
SEM-07–001 (Minera San Xavier), Secretariat Information Request pursuant to Article 21(1)(b) (March 7, 2008).Google Scholar
SEM-07–005 (Drilling Waste in Cunduacán), Determination pursuant to Article 14(3) (April 8, 2009).Google Scholar
SEM-07–005 (Drilling Waste in Cunduacán), Government of the United Mexican States Supplemental Response pursuant to Article 21(1)(b) (May 15, 2008).Google Scholar
SEM-08–001 (La Ciudadela Project), Government of the United Mexican States Supplemental Response pursuant to Article 21(1)(b) (May 26, 2010).Google Scholar
SEM-08–001 (La Ciudadela Project), Recommendation pursuant to Article 15(1) (August 12, 2010).Google Scholar
SEM-09–001 (Transgenic Maize in Chihuahua), Government of the United Mexican States Response pursuant to Article 14(3) (May 3, 2010).Google Scholar
SEM-09–001 (Transgenic Maize in Chihuahua), Recommendation pursuant to Article 15(1) (December 20, 2010).Google Scholar
SEM-09–002 (Wetlands in Manzanillo), Notification pursuant to Article 15(1) (August 19, 2013).Google Scholar
SEM-09–003 (Los Remedios National Park II), Government of the United Mexican States Response pursuant to Article 14(3) (December 20, 2010).Google Scholar
SEM-09–003 (Los Remedios National Park II), Recommendation pursuant to Article 15(1) (July 27, 2011).Google Scholar
SEM-96–003 (Oldman River I), Recommendation pursuant to Article 15(1) (April 2, 1997).Google Scholar
SEM-97–001 (B.C. Hydro), Council Resolution 98–07 pursuant to Article 15(2) (June 24, 1998).Google Scholar
SEM-97–001 (B.C. Hydro), Government of Canada Response pursuant to Article 14(3) (July 21, 1997).Google Scholar
SEM-98–004 (BC Mining), Council Resolution 01–11 pursuant to Article 15(2) (November 16, 2001).Google Scholar
SEM-98–004 (BC Mining), Government of Canada Response pursuant to Article 14(3) (September 8, 1999).Google Scholar
SEM-99–001 and SEM 00–002 (Methanex), Determination pursuant to Article 14(3) (June 30, 2000).Google Scholar
SEM-99–001 and SEM 00–002 (Methanex), Government of the United States of America Response pursuant to Article 14(3) (May 30, 2000).Google Scholar
Aust, Anthony. Modern Treaty Law and Practice, 2nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Black's Law Dictionary Free Online Legal Dictionary, 2nd ed.Google Scholar
Markell, David. “The North American Commission for Environmental Cooperation After Ten Years: Lessons About Institutional Structure and Public Participation in Governance.” (2004) 26 Loyola of Los Angeles International & Comparative Law Review, 341–57.Google Scholar
Markell, David. “The Role of Spotlighting Procedures in Promoting Citizen Participation, Transparency, and Accountability.” (2010) 45 Wake Forest Law Review, 425–67.Google Scholar
Pacheco-Vega, Raúl. “Las denuncias ciudadanas sobre cumplimiento ambiental en América del Norte (1996–2012): perspectivas sobre la sociedad civil ambientalista norteamericana.” (2013) 8 NORTEAMÉRICA, 77–108.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Solano, Pablo. “Choosing the Right Whistle: The Development of the ‘Environmental Law’ Concept under the Citizen Submission Process,” Chapter 3 of this volume.Google Scholar
Ten-year Review and Assessment Committee. “Ten Years of North American Environmental Cooperation.” Report of the Ten-year Review and Assessment Committee to the Council of the Commission for Environmental Cooperation (June 15, 2004).Google Scholar