Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- PREFACE
- CHAPTER I THE BRITISH CONSTITUTION
- CHAPTER II THE CHOICE OF A PRIME MINISTER
- CHAPTER III THE FORMATION OF A GOVERNMENT
- CHAPTER IV THE ADMINISTRATION
- CHAPTER V MINISTERS AT WORK
- CHAPTER VI INTER-DEPARTMENTAL RELATIONS
- CHAPTER VII TREASURY CONTROL
- CHAPTER VIII THE PRIME MINISTER
- CHAPTER IX THE CABINET
- CHAPTER X WAR AND DEFENCE
- CHAPTER XI ECONOMIC POLICY
- CHAPTER XII CONSTITUTIONAL MONARCHY
- CHAPTER XIII THE PERSONAL PREROGATIVES: DISMISSAL OF MINISTERS, DISSOLUTION OF PARLIAMENT, CREATION OF PEERS
- CHAPTER XIV PATRONAGE AND HONOURS
- CHAPTER XV GOVERNMENT AND PARLIAMENT
- APPENDIX I. GOVERNMENTS SINCE 1835
- APPENDIX II. EXAMPLES OF GOVERNMENTS
- APPENDIX III. THE PREROGATIVE OF DISSOLUTION
- APPENDIX IV. BIOGRAPHICAL AND BIBLIOGRAPHICAL NOTES
- INDEX
CHAPTER XV - GOVERNMENT AND PARLIAMENT
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 23 September 2009
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- PREFACE
- CHAPTER I THE BRITISH CONSTITUTION
- CHAPTER II THE CHOICE OF A PRIME MINISTER
- CHAPTER III THE FORMATION OF A GOVERNMENT
- CHAPTER IV THE ADMINISTRATION
- CHAPTER V MINISTERS AT WORK
- CHAPTER VI INTER-DEPARTMENTAL RELATIONS
- CHAPTER VII TREASURY CONTROL
- CHAPTER VIII THE PRIME MINISTER
- CHAPTER IX THE CABINET
- CHAPTER X WAR AND DEFENCE
- CHAPTER XI ECONOMIC POLICY
- CHAPTER XII CONSTITUTIONAL MONARCHY
- CHAPTER XIII THE PERSONAL PREROGATIVES: DISMISSAL OF MINISTERS, DISSOLUTION OF PARLIAMENT, CREATION OF PEERS
- CHAPTER XIV PATRONAGE AND HONOURS
- CHAPTER XV GOVERNMENT AND PARLIAMENT
- APPENDIX I. GOVERNMENTS SINCE 1835
- APPENDIX II. EXAMPLES OF GOVERNMENTS
- APPENDIX III. THE PREROGATIVE OF DISSOLUTION
- APPENDIX IV. BIOGRAPHICAL AND BIBLIOGRAPHICAL NOTES
- INDEX
Summary
The Strength of the Government
It is not untrue to say that the most important part of Parliament is the Opposition in the House of Commons. The function of Parliament is not to govern but to criticise. Its criticism, too, is directed not so much towards a fundamental modification of the Government's policy as towards the education of public opinion. The Government's majority exists to support the Government. The purpose of the Opposition is to secure a majority against the Government at the next general election and thus to replace the Government. This does not imply that a Government may not be defeated in the House of Commons. Nor does it imply that parliamentary criticism may not persuade the Government to modify, or even to withdraw, its proposals. These qualifications are important; but they do not destroy the truth of the principle that the Government governs and the Opposition criticises. Failure to understand this simple principle is one of the causes of the failure of so many of the progeny of the Mother of Parliaments and of the supersession of parliamentary government by dictatorships.
It is said that the House of Commons controls Parliament; and the lawyers point to the power of the House of Commons to refuse to legalise the Army and the Air Force and to refuse supplies, and thus to compel a Government to resign.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Cabinet Government , pp. 472 - 510Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 1959
- 2
- Cited by