[After the English Revolution of 1688, and the outbreak of war between William III and Louis XIV, Huguenots in the Netherlands were torn between loyalty to their native land and loyalty to their adopted republic. Some, such as Jurieu, wrote in favour of William, Protestantism, and popular sovereignty, while others stayed silent. In his account of the Huguenot author of the Franco-Gallia, Bayle reveals another strategy. He reminds contemporaries that in the sixteenth century Protestants and Catholics had taught, in turn, that peoples were sovereign. For some doctrines were like ‘birds of passage’ – in ‘one country in summer’ and in another ‘in winter’. In 1673, Hotman had proposed an elected ruler as an alternative to the Catholic regency; but the elective argument had ‘migrated’ to the Catholic House of Guise in 1584 when the Protestant Henry of Navarre acceded as legitimate heir.]