Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-xbtfd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-16T14:21:26.650Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

3 - Critical Legal Studies – The Missing Years

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 June 2012

Robin West
Affiliation:
Georgetown University, Washington DC
Get access

Summary

The Anglo-American critical legal studies (CLS) movement came to maturity in the late 1970s, motivated, in part, from a sense of dissatisfaction with the state of doctrinal legal scholarship. Legal scholarship, the critical scholars argued, had become deadeningly, deeply conservative, and not in the ordinary sense. That is, it was not conservative because of a contested but defensible view that law-as-it-is is worthy of conservation, or even that law by definition is simply something that must be preserved and defended against all comers. Rather, legal scholarship had become unduly conservative – describing law in such a way as to render it resistant to change, reform, or criticism – for a host of transparently indefensible reasons: a lack of moral and political imagination among legal academics, a felt lack of responsibility for the moral or political consequences of existing law, a complacency bordering on complicity with law's injustices, an unwillingness to do the work or take the risks of arguing for change, more simply, a lazy satisfaction with the status quo, or at best a false belief in the necessity of things staying more or less as they are, with only modest changes in the doctrinal margins up for grabs, as it were. With the possible exception of the American realists of the 1920s and 1930s, there has never before or since been an American academic legal movement so clearly, explicitly, and unapologetically driven by a critical, reformist, and for the most part genuinely radical and left-wing political impulse. The central point of the critical legal studies movement of the 1970s through the mid-1980s was to make the case for fundamental legal change: first, for its possibility, and second, for its moral necessity. The doctrinal law taught in American law schools, the critics claimed, was a substantial hindrance to that change. The attitude and methods surrounding it, however, were even greater obstacles. Law – particularly common law and constitutional law – is simply neither as necessary nor as justified as believed and taught by the mainstream of legal thought, doctrine, and pedagogy, or so the critics argued.

Type
Chapter
Information
Normative Jurisprudence
An Introduction
, pp. 107 - 176
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Print publication year: 2011

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Unger, Roberto MangabeiraThe Critical Legal Studies MovementHarvard Law Review 93.6 1983 561Google Scholar
Kennedy, DuncanLegal Education as Training for HierarchyThe Politics of Law: A Progressive CritiqueNew YorkPantheon Books 1998 40
Gordon, RobertNew Developments in Legal TheoryThe Politics of Law289
Singer, JosephBaseline Questions in Legal Reasoning: The Example of Property in JobsGeorgia Law Review 23.4 1989 911Google Scholar
Gordon, Robert WUnfreezing Legal Reality: Critical Approaches to LawFlorida State University Law Review 15.2 1987 195Google Scholar
, GordonNew Developments in Legal TheoryThe Politics of Law289
Unger, Roberto MangabeiraFalse Necessity: Antinecessitarian Social Theory in the Service of Radical DemocracyCambridgeCambridge University Press 1987
Kelman, MarkA Guide to Critical Legal StudiesCambridgeHarvard University Press 1987
Kennedy, DuncanDistributive and Paternalist Motives in Contract and Tort Law, with Special Reference to Compulsory Terms and Unequal Bargaining PowerMaryland Law Review 41.4 1982 563Google Scholar
Abel, Richard LShould Tort Protect Property against Accidental Loss?San Diego Law Review 23 1986 79Google Scholar
Tushnet, MarkAn Essay on RightsTexas Law Review 62.8 1984 1363Google Scholar
Seidman, Louis MichaelBrown and MirandaCalifornia Law Review 80 1992 673Google Scholar
, SeidmanRubashov's Question: Self-Incrimination and the Problem of Coerced PreferencesYale Journal of Law and the Humanities 2.1 1990 149Google Scholar
Matsuda, Mari JPublic Response to Racist Speech: Considering the Victim's StoryMichigan Law Review 87 1989 2320Google Scholar
Horwitz, Morton JRightsHarvard Civil Rights–Civil Liberties Law Review 23 1988 393Google Scholar
Freeman, Alan DavidLegitimizing Racial Discrimination through Antidiscrimination Law: A Critical Review of Supreme Court Doctrine,Minnesota Law Review 62.6 1978 1049Google Scholar
Bell, DerrickServing Two Masters: Integration Ideals and Client Interests in School Desegregation Litigation,Yale Law Journal 85.4 1976 470Google Scholar
Bell, and the Interest-Convergence Dilemma,Harvard Law Review 93.3 1980 518Google Scholar
Bell, Faces at the Bottom of the Well: The Permanence of RacismNew YorkBasic Books 1992
1965
1973
MacKinnon, CatharineFeminism Unmodified: Discourses on Life and LawCambridgeHarvard University Press 1987 93
Unger, Roberto MangabeiraPassion: An Essay on PersonalityNew YorkThe Free Press 1984
R. Mangabeira Unger, False NecessityNew YorkFree Press 1975
Gabel, PeterThe Phenomenology of Rights-Consciousness and the Pact of the Withdrawn Selves,Texas Law Review 62.8 1984 1563Google Scholar
Gabel, Kennedy, DuncanRoll Over Beethoven,Stanford Law Review 36.1 1984 1Google Scholar
Gabel, PeterBook Review: Taking Rights SeriouslyHarvard Law Review 91.1 1977 302Google Scholar
Kennedy, DuncanThe Structure of Blackstone's CommentariesBuffalo Law Review 28.2 1979 205Google Scholar
Gabel, PeterBuilding Power and Breaking Images: Critical Legal Theory and the Practice of LawNYU Review of Social 11.3 1982 369Google Scholar
, GabelCritical Legal Studies as a Spiritual PracticePepperdine Law Review 36 2008 515Google Scholar
Tushnet, MarkCritical Legal Studies: An Introduction to Its Origins and Underpinnings,Journal of Legal Education 36 1986 505Google Scholar
Singer, Joseph WilliamThe Player and the Cards: Nihilism and Legal Theory,The Yale Law Journal 94.1 1984 1Google Scholar
Dalton, ClareAn Essay in the Deconstruction of Contract DoctrineYale Law Journal 94.5 1985 997Google Scholar
Kelman, MarkTrashing,Stanford Law Review 36 1984 293Google Scholar
Kelman, Interpretive Construction in the Substantive Criminal Law,Stanford Law Review 33.4 1981 591Google Scholar
Gabel, Kennedy, Roll Over BeethovenYale Law Journal 90.5 1981 1229Google Scholar
McCulskey, MarthaThinking with Wolves: Left Legal Theory after the Right's RiseBuffalo Law Review 54 2007 1191Google Scholar
Posner, Richard ALegal Scholarship TodayHarvard Law Review 115.5 2002 1314Google Scholar
Tushnet, MarkRenormalizing Bush v. Gore: An Anticipatory Intellectual HistoryGeorgetown Law Journal 90.1 2001 113Google Scholar
Brown, WendyHalley, JanetLeft Legalism/Left CritiqueDurhamDuke University Press 2002
Kennedy, DuncanThe Critique of Rights in Critical Legal Studies,Left Legalism/Left Critique 178
Warner, MichaelThe Trouble with Normal: Sex, Politics, and the Ethics of Queer LifeNew YorkFree Press 1999
Schlag, PierreSpam Jurisprudence, Air Law, and the Rank Anxiety of Nothing Happening (A Report on the State of the Art)Georgetown Law Journal 97.3 2009 803Google Scholar
Kennedy, DuncanSexy Dressing EtcCambridgeHarvard University Press 1993
Kennedy, A Semiotics of Critique,Cardozo Law Review 22 2001 1147Google Scholar
Kelman, MarkCould Lawyers Stop Recession – Speculations on Law and Macroeconomics,Stanford Law Review 45.5 1993 1215Google Scholar
Kelman, Context-Dependence in Legal Decision Making,Journal of Legal Studies 25 1996 287Google Scholar
Kelman, Market Discrimination and Groups,Stanford Law Review 53.4 2001Google Scholar
Gordon, Robert W.Lawyers, Scholars, and the Middle Ground,Michigan Law Review 91.8 1993Google Scholar
Gordon, Imprudence and Partnership: Starr's OIC and the Clinton-Lewinsky Affair,Fordham Law Review 68.3 1999 639Google Scholar
Singer, Joseph WilliamA Pragmatic Guide to Conflicts,Boston University Law Review 70.5 1990 731Google Scholar
Singer, No Right to Exclude: Public Accommodations and Private Property,Northwestern University Law Review 90.4 1995 1283Google Scholar
Singer, Entitlement: The Paradoxes of PropertyNew HavenYale University Press 2000
Forbath, William E.Why This Rights Talk Is Different from All Other Rights Talk: Demoting the Court and Reimagining the Constitution,Stanford Law Review 46.6 1994 1771Google Scholar
Forbath, Habermas's Constitution: A History, Guide, and Critique,Law and Social Inquiry 23.4 1998 969Google Scholar
Forbath, Caste, Class, and Equal Citizenship,Michigan Law Review 98:1 1999 1Google Scholar
Schlag, PierreNormativity and the Politics of Form,University of Pennsylvania Law Review 139.4 1991 801Google Scholar
Schlag, How to Do Things with the First Amendment,University of Colorado Law Review 64.4 1993 1095Google Scholar
Schlag, Law and Phrenology,Harvard Law Review 110.4 1997 877Google Scholar
Tushnet, Mark V.The Degradation of Constitutional Discourse,Georgetown Law Journal 81.2 1992 251Google Scholar
Tushnet, Policy Distortion and Democratic Debilitation: Comparative Illumination of the Countermajoritarian Difficulty,Michigan Law Review 94.2 1995 245Google Scholar
Tushnet, Making Civil Rights Law: Thurgood Marshall and the Supreme CourtOxfordOxford University Press 1996
Tushnet, Taking the Constitution away from the CourtsPrincetonPrinceton University Press 2000
Peller, GaryRace Consciousness,Duke Law Journal 1990.4 1990 758Google Scholar
Peller, Crenshaw, KimberleThe Contradictions of Mainstream Constitutional Theory,UCLA Law Review 45.6 1998 1683Google Scholar
Holmes, Rachelle Y.Deconstructing the Rules of Corporate Tax,Akron Tax Journal 25.1 2010 1Google Scholar
Wendel, Peter T.Deconstructing Legal Analysis: A 1L PrimerFrederickAspen Publishers 2009
, FreemanRacism, Rights, and the Quest for Equality of Opportunity: A Critical Legal EssayHarvard Civil Rights–Civil Liberties Law Review 23.2 1988 295Google Scholar
Crenshaw, Kimberle WilliamsRace, Reform, and Retrenchment: Transformation and Legitimation in Antidiscrimination LawHarvard Law Review 101.7 1988 1331Google Scholar
Kelman, MarkConsumption Theory, Production Theory, and Ideology in the Coase TheoremSouthern California Law Review 52.3 1979Google Scholar
Peller, Race ConsciousnessCritical Race Theory: Key Writings That Formed the MovementNew YorkThe New Press 1995
Crenshaw, Race, Reform, and RetrenchmentHarvard Civil Rights–Civil Liberties Law Review 22.2 1987 301Google Scholar
Critical Legal Studies and the Realities of Race – Does the Fundamental Contradiction Have a Corollary?Harvard Civil Rights–Civil Liberties Law Review 23.2 1988 407
Gaziano, ToddWhy the Personal Mandate to Buy Health Insurance Is Unprecedented and Unconstitutional 2009
West, RobinLaw's NobilityYale Journal of Law and Feminism 17.2 2005 385Google Scholar
Hale, Robert LBargaining, Duress, and Economic LibertyColumbia Law Review 43.5 1943 603Google Scholar
1923
West, RobinAuthority, Autonomy, and Choice: The Role of Consent in the Moral and Political Visions of Franz Kafka and Richard Posner,Harvard Law Review 99.2 1985 384Google Scholar
West, Submission, Choice, and Ethics: A Rejoinder to Judge Posner,Harvard Law Review 99 1986 1449Google Scholar
Posner, Richard AThe Economics of JusticeCambridgeHarvard University Press 1981 61
West, RobinFrom Choice to Reproductive JusticeYale Law Journal 118.7 2009 1394Google Scholar
Elster, JonSour Grapes: Studies in the Subversion of RationalityCambridgeCambridge University Press 1983
Soble, AlanPower, Nicholas 2008
Barnett, Randy E.Kates, Don B.Under Fire: The New Consensus on the Second Amendment,Emory Law Journal 45.4 1996 1139Google Scholar
Levinson, SanfordAssessing ,International Journal of Constitution Law 7.2 2009 316Google Scholar
Levinson, Why Didn't the Supreme Court Take My Advice in the Heller Case – Some Speculative Responses to an Egocentric Question,Hastings Law Journal 60.0 2008 1491Google Scholar
Bush, George WBoies, DavidBush v. Gore 531 2000
Answers to Questions about Marriage EqualityWashington, DCHuman Rights Campaign 2009
Eskridge Jr, William N.Spedale, Darren RGay Marriage: For Better or Worse? What We've Learned from the EvidenceNew YorkOxford University Press 2006
Eskridge Jr, William N.The Case for Same Sex Marriage: From Sexual Liberty to Civilized CommitmentNew YorkFree Press 1996
West, RobinMarriage, Sexuality, and GenderBoulderParadigm Publishers 2007
MacKinnon, CatharineThe Road Not Taken: Sex Equality in ,Ohio State Law Journal 65.5 2004 1081Google Scholar
Sunstein, CassLiberty After Lawrence,Ohio State Law Journal 65.5 2004 1059Google Scholar
Greenwood, Daniel J. HEssential Speech: Why Corporate Speech Is Not FreeIowa Law Journal 83.5 1989 995Google Scholar
Yuracko, Kimberly AEducation Off the GridCalifornia Law Review 96.1 2008 123Google Scholar
Reich, RobertTesting the Boundaries of Parental Authority over Education: The Case of HomeschoolingMoral and Political EducationMacedo, StephenTamir, YaelNew YorkNew York University Press 2002 275
Nozick, RobertNagel, ThomasDworkin, RonaldScanlon, T. MRawls, JohnAssisted Suicide: The Philosophers’ BriefThe New York Review of Books 1997Google Scholar
Seigel, Reva B.A Short History of Sexual Harassment,Directions in Sexual Harassment LawSeigel, Reva BMacKinnon, CatharineNew HavenYale University Press 2003 1
West, RobinSex, Law, and ConsentThe Ethics of Consent: Theory and PracticeMiller, Franklin GWertheimer, AlanNew YorkOxford University Press 2010 221
Halley, JanetSexuality Harassment,Left Legalism/Left Critique80
The Politics of Injury: A Review of Robin West's Caring for Justice,Unbound: Harvard Journal of the Legal Left 2005 65PrincetonPrinceton University Press 2006
Halley, IanQueer Theory by MenDuke Journal of Gender Law and Policy 11 2004 7Google Scholar
Kristman, Lawrence DSheridan, AlanNew YorkRoutledge 1988 178
Kennedy, DavidThe Spectacle and the LibertineAftermath: The Clinton Impeachment and the Presidency in the Age of Political SpectacleKaplan, Leonard VMoran, Beverly INew YorkNew York University Press 2001 279
Bersani, LeoIs the Rectum a GraveOctober 43 1987 197Google Scholar
Spindelman, MarcSexuality's LawColumbia Journal of Gender and the Law 20.2 2011Google Scholar
Bell, DerrickThe Dialectics of School DesegregationAlabama Law Review 32.2 1981 281Google Scholar
Freeman, Foreword: The Civil Rights ChroniclesHarvard Law Review 99.1 1985 4Google Scholar
Freeman, The Republican Revival and Racial PoliticsYale Law Journal 97.8 1988 1609Google Scholar
Halley, JanetFrom the International to the Local in Feminist Legal Responses to Rape, Prostitution/Sex Work, and Sex Trafficking: Four Studies in Contemporary Governance FeminismHarvard Journal of Law and Gender 29.2 2006 335Google Scholar
Gabel 1568
Williams, JAlchemical Notes: Reconstructing Ideals from Deconstructed RightsHarvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review 22.2 1987 401Google Scholar
Kennedy, DuncanPsycho-Social CLS: A Comment on the Cardozo SymposiumCardozo Law Review 6.4 1985 1013Google Scholar
West, RobinDeconstructing the CLS-Fem SplitWisconsin Women's Law Journal 2 1986 85Google Scholar
West, RobinAre There Nothing but Texts in This Class? Interpreting the Interpretive Turns in Legal ThoughtChicago-Kent Law Review 76.2 2000 1125Google Scholar
Rosenberg, Gerald NThe Hollow Hope: Can Courts Bring about Social Change?ChicagoUniversity of Chicago Press 1991
Tushnet, MarkRed, White, and Blue: A Critical Analysis of Constitutional LawCambridgeHarvard University Press 1988 1
2002
, MacKinnonFeminism UnmodifiedReflections on Sex Equality under the Law 100.5 1991 1281Google Scholar
Nourse, VictoriaWhere Violence, Relationship, and Equality Meet: The Violence against Women Act's Civil Rights Remedy,Wisconsin Women's Law Journal 11.1 1996 1Google Scholar
MacKinnon, CatharineDisputing Male Sovereignty: On ,Harvard Law Review 114.1 2000 135Google Scholar
Siegel, Reva B.Rule of Love: Wife Beating as Prerogative and Privacy,Yale Law Journal 105.8 1996 2117Google Scholar
Young, Angie KAssessing the Family and Medical Leave Act in Terms of Gender Equality, Work/Family Balance, and the Needs of ChildrenMichigan Journal of Gender and the 5.1 1998 113Google Scholar
Silbaugh, KatharineIs the Work-Family Conflict Pathological or Normal under the FMLA? The Potential of the FMLA to Cover Ordinary Work-Family ConflictsWashington University Journal of Law and Policy 15 2004 193Google Scholar
Selmi, MichaelIs Something Better Than Nothing? Critical Reflections on Ten Years of the FMLAWashington University Journal of Law and Policy 15 2004 65Google Scholar

Save book to Kindle

To save this book to your Kindle, first ensure coreplatform@cambridge.org is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part of your Kindle email address below. Find out more about saving to your Kindle.

Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations. ‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. ‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.

Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service.

Available formats
×

Save book to Dropbox

To save content items to your account, please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account. Find out more about saving content to Dropbox.

Available formats
×

Save book to Google Drive

To save content items to your account, please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account. Find out more about saving content to Google Drive.

Available formats
×