Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Acknowledgments
- Abbreviations
- Introduction
- 1 The Henrician canons
- 2 The Reformatio legum ecdesiasticarum
- Signs used in the text
- The Reformation of the Ecclesiastical Laws
- Royal proclamation of King Edward VI
- 1 Of The Highest Trinity And The Catholic Faith
- 2 Of Heresies
- 3 Of Judgments Against Heresies
- 4 [Of] Blasphemy in Which
- 5 Of Sacraments
- 6 Of Idolatry and Other Like Crimes
- 7 Of Preachers
- 8 Of Matrimony
- 9 Of Degrees Prohibited in Matrimony
- 10 Of Adultery and Divorce
- 11 Of Those to be Admitted to Ecclesiastical Benefices
- 12 Of The Resignation or Abandonment of Benefices
- 13 Of The Exchange of Ecclesiastical Benefices
- 14 Of Purgation
- 15 Of Dilapidations
- 16 Of Alienating or Letting Church Property
- 17 Of an Election
- 18 Of Conferring Ecclesiastical Benefices Without Loss
- 19 Of The Services Of The Church
- 20 Of The Church And its Ministers, And their Offices
- 21 Of Churchwardens
- 22 Of Parish Boundaries1
- 23 Of Schools And Schoolmasters1
- 24 Of Universities, Particularly of the Heads of Colleges
- 25 Of Tithes
- 26 Of Visitations
- 27 Of Testaments
- 28 Of Ecclesiastical Penalties
- 29 Of Suspension
- 30 Of the Deduction of Fruits or Sequestration, as it is Commonly Called, for Different Reasons
- 31 Of Deprivation
- 32 Of Excommunication
- 33 A form for Reconciling Excommunicates
- 34 Of Judgments, and when Someone Ought to take Action or Agree to Them
- 35 Of Crimes
- 36 Of Judgments
- 37 Of the Office and Jurisdiction of all Judges
- 38 Of the Joinder of Issue
- 39 Of Oaths and Perjury
- 40 Of the Oath Against Calumny
- 41 Of Trials
- 42 Of Possession
- 43 Of [The] Credence [Given to Documents]
- 44 Of the Crime of Forgery
- 45 Of Witnesses and their Sayings
- 46 Of Custom
- 47 Of Prescriptions
- 48 Of Violent Striking of Clerks
- 49 Of Presumptions
- 50 Of Defamations
- 51 Of Respitings or Dilations
- 52 Of Exceptions
- 53 Of the Sentence and Judgment Rendered
- 54 Of Appeals
- 55 Of the Rules of Law
- 3 Appendixes
- 4 Indexes of sources and references
- Subject index
- Bibliography
- Miscellaneous Endmatter
53 - Of the Sentence and Judgment Rendered
from 2 - The Reformatio legum ecdesiasticarum
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 September 2018
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Acknowledgments
- Abbreviations
- Introduction
- 1 The Henrician canons
- 2 The Reformatio legum ecdesiasticarum
- Signs used in the text
- The Reformation of the Ecclesiastical Laws
- Royal proclamation of King Edward VI
- 1 Of The Highest Trinity And The Catholic Faith
- 2 Of Heresies
- 3 Of Judgments Against Heresies
- 4 [Of] Blasphemy in Which
- 5 Of Sacraments
- 6 Of Idolatry and Other Like Crimes
- 7 Of Preachers
- 8 Of Matrimony
- 9 Of Degrees Prohibited in Matrimony
- 10 Of Adultery and Divorce
- 11 Of Those to be Admitted to Ecclesiastical Benefices
- 12 Of The Resignation or Abandonment of Benefices
- 13 Of The Exchange of Ecclesiastical Benefices
- 14 Of Purgation
- 15 Of Dilapidations
- 16 Of Alienating or Letting Church Property
- 17 Of an Election
- 18 Of Conferring Ecclesiastical Benefices Without Loss
- 19 Of The Services Of The Church
- 20 Of The Church And its Ministers, And their Offices
- 21 Of Churchwardens
- 22 Of Parish Boundaries1
- 23 Of Schools And Schoolmasters1
- 24 Of Universities, Particularly of the Heads of Colleges
- 25 Of Tithes
- 26 Of Visitations
- 27 Of Testaments
- 28 Of Ecclesiastical Penalties
- 29 Of Suspension
- 30 Of the Deduction of Fruits or Sequestration, as it is Commonly Called, for Different Reasons
- 31 Of Deprivation
- 32 Of Excommunication
- 33 A form for Reconciling Excommunicates
- 34 Of Judgments, and when Someone Ought to take Action or Agree to Them
- 35 Of Crimes
- 36 Of Judgments
- 37 Of the Office and Jurisdiction of all Judges
- 38 Of the Joinder of Issue
- 39 Of Oaths and Perjury
- 40 Of the Oath Against Calumny
- 41 Of Trials
- 42 Of Possession
- 43 Of [The] Credence [Given to Documents]
- 44 Of the Crime of Forgery
- 45 Of Witnesses and their Sayings
- 46 Of Custom
- 47 Of Prescriptions
- 48 Of Violent Striking of Clerks
- 49 Of Presumptions
- 50 Of Defamations
- 51 Of Respitings or Dilations
- 52 Of Exceptions
- 53 Of the Sentence and Judgment Rendered
- 54 Of Appeals
- 55 Of the Rules of Law
- 3 Appendixes
- 4 Indexes of sources and references
- Subject index
- Bibliography
- Miscellaneous Endmatter
Summary
When a judge can follow charges and proofs against his conscience.
What is decreed by the learned and wise is helpful, that no one should follow any thought of his own which he has brought with him from home to the judgment, but he should decide according to the charges and proofs. But this rule must obtain when a judge is led by certain frivolous arguments to think that he understands the case differently from what has been proved. For in that case he must follow the charges and proofs rather than his opinion and conscience which is formed by something in his imagination. But if the judge has an undoubted conscience concerning the matter, then he must in no way determine anything against it, on account of the charges and proofs. But even in that case, a distinction must be made. For if a judge has a conscience against the accused, and yet in the trial the accused is proved to be innocent, then he must not condemn him on the basis of his conscience, by which he knows that he is [guilty innocent], but absolve him according to what has been proved. For even ﹛ i f ﹜ he does so, it cannot be said that he has done it against his conscience, because he has absolved the accused not as an innocent man, but only on the basis of the process of judgment. But if the judge has a conscience in favour of the accused, in spite of what is charged and proved, then he must not decide against his undoubted conscience. For a judge is to be believed if he alleges conscience in support of another person, if he can prove it.
Since a judge cannot supply elements missing from the trial, he must determine how he can bring his conscience to bear in favour of the accused, in spite of the charges and proofs, in such a way that he does not impinge on those constitutions by which it is forbidden to add anything to the trial. Therefore in such a case he should declare his conscience to a superior judge by consulting with him.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Tudor Church ReformThe Henrician Canons Of 1535 and the Reformatio Legum Ecclesiasticarum, pp. 682 - 697Publisher: Boydell & BrewerPrint publication year: 2000