The Catholic Conundrum

Jon Gjerde

doi:10.1017/CBO9780511845758.004

2 - The Catholic Conundrum

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 June 2012

Jon Gjerde

Edited by

S. Deborah Kang

Show author details

Jon Gjerde: Affiliation:
University of California, Berkeley
S. Deborah Kang: Affiliation:
University of California, Berkeley

Book contents

Get access

Summary

The question now pressing itself upon the American people is, to determine their Religion, as our fathers did the character of their political institutions. . . . With the free exertion of Reason, with the natural impulses of our instincts, and with the silent influences of our noble institutions, the American people will rise in the strength of its manhood and proclaim itself Catholic.

Isaac Hecker, 1857

In 1836, John Hughes, who would later become archbishop of New York City, and John Breckinridge, secretary and general agent of the Board of Education of the Presbyterian Church, engaged in a series of debates in Philadelphia considering whether either Roman Catholicism or Presbyterianism was inimical to civil or religious liberty in the United States (see Fig. 3). The debate was long in coming. As early as 1832, Breckinridge tendered a challenge in the periodical Christian Advocate to anyone who wished to debate whether the “Protestant Religion” was the “Religion of Christ.” Hughes, who had been ordained to the priesthood only six years before and who would become a towering figure in American Catholicism, took up the challenge. Once they agreed on the ground rules of the debate, each developed his arguments, which were published in sectarian journals beginning in 1833. Three years later, Breckinridge and Hughes met in another series of debates, the content of which was also published.

Information

Type: Chapter
Information: Catholicism and the Shaping of Nineteenth-Century America , pp. 61 - 95

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511845758.004 [Opens in a new window]

Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Print publication year: 2011

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Book purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Hecker, I[saac] T.Aspirations of NatureNew YorkKirker, J. B. 1857 New YorkCatholic Publication House 1869 360Google Scholar

Billington, The Protestant Crusade, 1800–1860New YorkMacmillan 1938 62Google Scholar

Meyers, Mary AnnThe Children’s Crusade: Philadelphia Catholics and the Public Schools, 1840–1844Records of the American Catholic Historical Society of Philadelphia 75 1964 104Google Scholar

Controversy between the Rev. John Hughes, of the Roman Catholic Church and the Rev. John Breckinridge, of the Presbyterian Church, Relative to the Existing Differences in the Roman Catholic and Protestant ReligionsPhiladelphiaJoseph Whetham 1833

Catholic ControversyMillennial Harbinger 4 1833 537

Debates on the Roman Catholic ReligionChristian Examiner 23 1838 53

Ryan, Thomas R.Records of the American Catholic Historical Society of Philadelphia 89 1978 57

Shaw, RichardDagger John: The Unquiet Life and Times of Archbishop John Hughes of New YorkNew YorkPaulist Press 1977Google Scholar

Brann, Henry A.Most Reverend John Hughes, First Archbishop of New YorkNew YorkDodd, Mead 1892Google Scholar

Hassard, John R. G.Life of the Most Reverend John Hughes, D.D., First Archbishop of New YorkNew YorkAppleton 1866Google Scholar

Stern, William J.“How Dagger John Saved New York’s Irish,”Urbanities 7 1997 http://www.city-journal.org/html/7_2_a2.htmlGoogle Scholar

Spalding, M. J.D’Aubigne’s “History of the Great Reformation in Germany and Switzerland,” reviewed; or, The reformation in Germany examined in its instruments, causes, and manner, and in its influence on religion, government, literature and general civilizationBaltimoreJohn Murphy 1844Google Scholar

MiscellaneaNew YorkJoseph F. Wagner 1923

European Civilization. Protestantism and Catholicity Compared in Their Effects on the Civilization of EuropeBaltimoreJohn Murphy 1850

Laurence Moore, R.Selling God: American Religion in the Marketplace of CultureNew YorkOxford University Press 1994Google Scholar

Conser, Church and Confession: Conservative Theologians in Germany, England, and America, 1815–1866Macon, GAMercer University Press 1984Google Scholar

Spalding, Martin J.A History of the Protestant Reformation in Germany and Switzerland, and in England, Ireland, Scotland, the Netherlands, France and Northern Europe. In a Series of Essays Reviewing d’Aubigné, Menzel, Hallam, Bishop Short, Prescott, Ranke, Fryxell, and othersLouisville, KYWebb and Levering 1860 366Google Scholar

Øverland, OrmImmigrant Minds, American Identities: Making the United States Home, 1870–1930UrbanaUniversity of Illinois Press 2000Google Scholar

Kazal, Russell A.Becoming Old Stock: The Paradox of German-American IdentityPrinceton, NJPrinceton University Press 2004Google Scholar

Laurence Moore, R.Religious Outsiders and the Making of AmericansNew YorkOxford University Press 1986 48Google Scholar

New York City ElectionBoston Pilot 20 1844

Common Schools and Catholic ChildrenBoston Pilot 13 1840

New York City ElectionBoston Pilot 20 1844

Gjerde, JonThe Minds of the West: Ethnocultural Evolution in the Rural Middle West, 1830–1917Chapel HillUniversity of North Carolina Press 1997 59Google Scholar

Boston Pilot 1 1848

de Maistre, JosephThe Works of Joseph de MaistreLively, JackNew YorkMacmillan 1965Google Scholar

Ignaz Döllinger, Johann JosephA History of the ChurchLondonC. Dolman, T. Jones1840

Bossuet, Jacques BénigneThe History of the Variations of the Protestant ChristianityNew YorkD. and J. Sadlier 1845Google Scholar

Lehmann, HartmutMartin Luther in the American ImaginationMünchenWilhelm Fink Verlag 1988 164Google Scholar

Spalding, M. J.“Influence of Catholicity on Civil Liberty,”Spalding, M. J.Miscellanea: Comprising Reviews, Lectures, and Essays on Historical, Theological, and Miscellaneous SubjectsBaltimoreJohn Murphy 1866 132

D’Arcy McGee, ThomasThe Catholic History of North America. Five Discourses to Which Are Added Two Discourses on the Relations of Ireland and AmericaBostonPatrick Donahoe 1855

Rameur, E.“The Progress of the Church in the United States,”Catholic World 1 1865 1Google Scholar

The Irish in AmericaBoston Pilot 16 1841

Supplement to “Six Months in a Convent,” Confirming the Narrative of Rebecca Theresa Reed, by the Testimony of More than One Hundred Witnesses, Whose Statements Have Been Given to the CommitteeBostonRussell, Odiorne 1835

The Irish in AmericaBoston Pilot 16 1841

The Mission of AmericaBoston Pilot 18 1848

The Complete Works of the Most Rev. John Hughes, D.D., Archbishop of New YorkKehoe, LawrenceNew YorkAmerican News 1865 2:104

Foreigners and the Right of SuffrageBoston Pilot 28 1841

Schade, LouisThe Immigration into the United States of America, from a Statistical and National-Economical Point of ViewWashington, DCUnion Office 1856 12Google Scholar

Boston Emigrant SocietyBoston Pilot 23 1844

The EmigrantBoston Pilot 30 1840

Orestes Brownson“Native Americanism: A Few Words on Native Americanism,”Brownson’s Quarterly Review 1854 343Google Scholar

HungaryNew York Freeman’s Journal 1849 1

McGreevy, John T.Catholicism and American Freedom: A HistoryNew YorkW. W. Norton 2003 36Google Scholar

The Mission of AmericaBrownson’s Quarterly Review 1 1856 409

Brownson, A.The Works of Orestes A. BrownsonBrownson, Henry F.DetroitT. Nourse 1882 551Google Scholar

Ryan, Thomas R.Orestes A. Brownson’s Lectures in St Louis, Missouri, 1852 and 1854Records of the American Catholic Historical Society of Philadelphia 1978 54Google Scholar

McMahon, Francis E.Orestes Brownson on Church and StateTheological Studies 15 1954 189CrossRef Google Scholar

Kehoe, Complete Works of the Most Rev. John Hughes2:145

Brownson, OrestesOn the Origin and Ground of GovernmentUnited States Magazine and Democratic Review 13 1843 257Google Scholar

Smith, Elwyn A.“The Fundamental Church-State Tradition of the Catholic Church in the United States,”Church History 38 1969 486CrossRef Google Scholar

Dolan, Jay P.In Search of an American Catholicism: A History of Religion and Culture in TensionNew YorkOxford University Press 2002CrossRef Google Scholar

Gerber, David A.The Making of an American Pluralism: Buffalo, New York, 1825–1860UrbanaUniversity of Illinois Press 1989Google Scholar

Light, Dale B.Rome and the New Republic: Conflict and Community in Philadelphia Catholicism between the Revolution and the Civil WarNotre Dame, INUniversity of Notre Dame Press 1996Google Scholar

Carey, Patrick W.People, Priests, and Prelates: Ecclesiastical Democracy and the Tensions of TrusteeismNotre Dame, INNotre Dame University Press 1987 155ffGoogle Scholar

Carey, Patrick W.Orestes A. Brownson: American Religious WeathervaneGrand Rapids, MIWm. B. Eerdmans 2004Google Scholar

Brownson, A.Review of Politics 38 1976 3

Guttman, Allen“From Brownson to Eliot: The Conservative Theory of Church and State,”American Quarterly 17 1965 487CrossRef Google Scholar

Guilday, PeterThe National Pastorals of the American Hierarchy, 1792–1919Washington, DCNational Catholic Welfare Council 1923Google Scholar

Smith, Elwyn A.Religious Liberty in the United States: The Development of Church-State Thought Since the Revolutionary EraPhiladelphiaFortress Press 1973 185Google Scholar

Kelso, IsaacDanger in the Dark: A Tale of Intrigue and PriestcraftCincinnatiMoore, Anderson, Wilstach, and Keys 1854 37Google Scholar

, BoardmanA Lecture Delivered in the Walnut Street Presbyterian Church, Philadelphia, on Sunday Evening, December 28th, 1840PhiladelphiaHooker and Agnew 1841Google Scholar

Brownson, Orestes“A Review of George Bancroft’s ,”Brownson’s Quarterly Review 1852 156Google Scholar

Colwell, StephenThe Position of Christianity in the United States, in its Relations with our Political Institutions, and Specially with Reference to Religious Instruction in the Public SchoolsPhiladelphiaLippincott, Grambo 1854 144 156Google Scholar

Gjerde, JonFranson, Peter“‘Still the Inwardly Beautiful Bride of Christ’: The Development of Lutheranism in the United States,”Luther zwitschen den KulturenMedick, HansSchmidt, PeerGöttingenVandenhoeck and Ruprecht 2004 190Google Scholar

Carroll, EllaThe Star of the West; or, National Men and National MeasuresNew YorkMiller, Orton 1857 461Google Scholar

Barcus, James E.“Structuring the Rage Within: The Spiritual Autobiographies of Newman and Orestes Brownson,”Cithara 15 1975 55Google Scholar

The Brownson-Hecker CorrespondenceGower, Joseph F.Leliaert, Richard M.Notre Dame, INUniversity of Notre Dame Press 1979 76Google Scholar

Burrows, Mark S.“Catholic Revision of an American Myth,”Catholic Historical Review 76 1990 32Google Scholar

Carey, Patrick W.“Christian Socialism in the Early Brownson,”Records of the American Catholic Historical Society of Philadelphia 99 1988 30Google Scholar

Accessibility standard: Unknown

Accessibility compliance for the PDF of this book is currently unknown and may be updated in the future.